Below are phrases copied word for word from the thread, grouped as requested. Comment numbers are cited after each one. Where a category had little material, I say so.

**Problems**

- "It started at $8 a serving with the intro discount and crept up to $12.49 by month six." [c1]
- "paying restaurant-adjacent prices to wash my own dishes" [c1]
- "The intro discount is doing a lot of work in their marketing." [c2]
- "Nobody counts the leftover half bottles." [c8]
- "half bottles of fish sauce and mirin I never used again" [c7]
- "Our recycling bin was full by Tuesday." [c13]
- "the gel packs can't go down the drain" [c15]
- "Nobody is doing that every week." [c17]
- "the freezer drawer of shame" [c19]
- "By month four it was the same six proteins in different sauces." [c21]
- "the same chicken thigh four weeks in a row" [c27]
- "Credits don't make dinner on a Wednesday." [c28] (paraphrased in the thread as "credits don't make dinner on a Wednesday"; this is the exact wording of c28)
- "The box sat on the porch for 5 hours in July." [c34]
- "Ice packs melted, meat was warm." [c36]
- "the app kept logging me out. Missed the deadline twice." [c37]
- "Dark patterns. Pause instead is designed so you click it by mistake." [c54]
- "I clicked it by mistake. Got charged three weeks later." [c55]
- "The fish portions were sad." [c49]
- "Fewer vegetarian options" [c64]
- "The vegetarian menu went from 8 to 4 options for us." [c65]
- "Price went up / Delivery moved to Friday" [c64]
- "Same price, less food." [c70]
- "Recipes said 30 minutes but with chopping it was always 50+." [c77]
- "Our average was about 1.5x the printed time." [c80]
- "Delivery got moved from Tuesday to Friday without telling us." [c88]
- "The produce started arriving bruised, and once the avocado was basically liquid." [c91]

**Desired outcomes**

- "the kit saved us from the 6pm 'what's for dinner' argument" [c12]
- "I wanted boring and predictable on weeknights." [c26]
- "it taught me to cook" [c41]
- "I photographed every card before recycling it." [c43]
- "Use it for three months, keep the cards, quit." [c44]
- "Still worth it for us on the 3 busiest nights." [c74]
- "Switched to a weekly meal plan and a grocery pickup order. Cheaper and less packaging, but more planning." [c84]
- "A spreadsheet with 20 dinners we like. I rotate through it." [c86]
- "Always cook the seafood recipe on day one." [c60]
- "Every issue got a credit within an hour." [c94]

**Comparisons with alternatives**

- "I priced 9 recipes against my local store. Kit was $11.90 a serving, groceries came to $7.40" [c7]
- "groceries win by a mile" [c9]
- "For me groceries win by a mile." [c9]
- "The gap wasn't as big as people think." [c5]
- "Nobody expects cheaper than groceries. We expect the price at signup to be the price." [c68]
- "We kept ours... it's still worth it for us on the 3 busiest nights." [c74]
- "Switched to a weekly meal plan and a grocery pickup order." [c84]
- "Nobody's saying meal kits are a scam, just that the pricing isn't honest." [c82]
- "Beginners have empty pantries." [c11]
- "Which is exactly the person these kits aren't for." [c11]

**Notes**

- The thread has more material on problems than on desired outcomes or comparisons; the outcomes section is thin, and most of its phrases come from the handful of people who kept or valued the product.
- Several phrases are the OP's or are marked as the OP's. I did not attribute any phrase to a named person, and I left out the deleted and removed comments (c20, c40, c81) since they have no text.
- Some lines appear twice in the list above because they fit more than one category; I noted the citation each time.
- c28 is quoted as written; I used the wording that appears in the thread, not a paraphrase.